Why Employee Gift Cards Still Matter in 2025
The Evolution of Employee Appreciation
Gift cards have stood the test of time—and with good reason. As workforces become increasingly remote, global, and tech-savvy, companies are doubling down on simple, personalized ways to recognize employees. Gift cards check all the boxes: they're fast, versatile, and appreciated.
Data on Effectiveness of Gift Cards vs. Cash Rewards
According to recent employee recognition surveys, gift cards outperform cash in terms of perceived value and emotional impact. Employees are more likely to remember the item they purchased with a gift card than an equivalent cash bonus—making gift cards a smarter investment in long-term morale.
What Makes a Great Employee Gift Card?
Versatility
The best gift cards offer freedom. Whether it's for a favorite retailer, restaurant, or an open-loop Visa card, employees appreciate being able to choose what suits them.
No Hidden Fees
Fees can sour the experience. Cards that come with activation charges or expiration dates feel less like a reward and more like a headache. Platforms like Toasty eliminate these issues with truly fee-free options.
Easy Delivery
Speed matters. Digital gift cards should be delivered instantly and securely via email or SMS. Scheduling tools and bulk uploads are a must for larger teams.
Global Usability
For multinational companies, global access is crucial. Choose cards that work across borders and support various currencies.
The Top 10 Best Gift Cards for Employees in 2025
1. Toasty Choice Card
The gold standard in employee gifting. The Toasty Choice Card lets recipients redeem for hundreds of brands, including Visa, Amazon, Starbucks, and more. It’s digital, fee-free, customizable, and incredibly easy to send at scale.
2. Visa Virtual Gift Card
Accepted nearly everywhere, the Visa Virtual Gift Card provides flexibility while staying digital. It's perfect for remote or international teams. Toasty offers this card with no activation or usage fees.
3. Amazon Gift Card
Amazon remains a go-to for all things—from groceries to electronics. An Amazon gift card offers vast utility and is especially appreciated during holidays or birthdays.
4. Target Gift Card
Known for home goods, fashion, and everyday essentials, Target is a favorite among families and young professionals alike.
5. DoorDash Gift Card
Great for treating your employees to lunch, especially remote workers. With nationwide coverage and food delivery options, this one’s a crowd-pleaser.
6. Starbucks Gift Card
A perfect way to say "Thanks a latte." Ideal for quick morale boosts, casual rewards, or coffee-themed campaigns.
7. Walmart Gift Card
This all-purpose card works well for employees who prioritize practical rewards. It covers groceries, home items, and more.
8. Apple Gift Card
Perfect for tech lovers. Whether it’s a new app, music subscription, or Apple gear, this card adds a premium touch to your rewards program.
9. Google Play Gift Card
For Android users or mobile gamers, this card is a hit. Ideal for downloading apps, renting movies, or buying ebooks.
10. Charity Choice Gift Card
Show employees you support their values by letting them donate to a cause of their choice. A thoughtful and impactful option.
Comparing Digital vs. Physical Gift Cards for Teams
Pros and Cons of Digital
Digital gift cards are the default in 2025 for most companies—and for good reason. They’re fast, trackable, eco-friendly, and can be personalized with just a few clicks. Platforms like Toasty even offer automated tracking, email updates, and reissue options.
Pros:
- Instant delivery
- No shipping costs
- Easy to personalize and resend
- Better security and tracking
Cons:
- Requires a valid email
- Can be overlooked in crowded inboxes
Use Cases for Physical Cards
Physical gift cards still hold value in specific scenarios, such as:
- On-site celebrations
- Holiday gift bags
- Events or raffles
That said, their distribution logistics and risk of loss make them less ideal for large, distributed teams.
Which Option is Right for Your Workforce?
If your team is remote or hybrid, digital wins every time. If you're in-office and want to hand someone a reward personally, physical can work. Some companies even offer both.
How to Choose the Right Gift Card for Your Team
Consider Demographics and Location
What your team values varies by generation, location, and lifestyle. A software engineer in San Francisco might prefer Amazon or Apple, while a warehouse team in Kansas might appreciate Walmart or Visa cards.
Match Card to Reward Types
- Holiday gifts: Toasty Choice Card or Amazon
- Birthdays: Starbucks or DoorDash
- Performance bonuses: Visa or Target
- Team challenges: Charity Choice for feel-good impact
Offering Choice vs. Control
The best option? Give employees the power to choose. The Toasty Choice Card enables each person to select from thousands of brands—reducing friction and maximizing satisfaction.
Customization Options for Employee Gift Cards
Branding with Logos
With Toasty, every digital card can include your company’s logo, reinforcing employer branding with every reward.
Personalized Messages
Don’t just send a reward—send a message that matters. A “Thank you for going the extra mile” means more than a generic “Here’s your reward.”
Seasonal Templates and Campaign Themes
Celebrate the seasons with festive themes. Whether it’s New Year’s, Employee Appreciation Week, or Diwali, Toasty lets you match your design to the moment.
Budgeting for Gift Cards in Your Employee Recognition Program
Setting Tiers and Milestones
Create levels: $25 for birthdays, $50 for anniversaries, $100+ for major wins. This keeps rewards consistent and meaningful.
Tracking ROI and Redemption
Toasty’s dashboard provides insights into redemption rates, helping HR and finance teams measure impact and adjust programs.
Recapture Unused Value with Toasty
Unused card? Toasty lets you reclaim 70% of the funds back into your budget—something most platforms don’t offer.
Mistakes to Avoid When Sending Gift Cards to Employees
Overcomplicating Redemption
Skip codes and clunky portals. Use platforms like Toasty where employees click once to access their card.
Ignoring Expiration or Fees
Some gift cards eat into value over time. Always choose no-fee, no-expiry cards like those on Toasty.
Not Tracking Delivery
If you’re not monitoring which cards bounce or go unopened, you’re wasting budget. Use a platform with full tracking and resend options.
Real-Life Examples of Effective Gift Card Programs
Employee Anniversary Campaigns
One HR manager set up automated Toasty deliveries for every work anniversary—employees received a customized card at 9 AM on their milestone day.
Sales Team Incentives
A SaaS sales director used Toasty to instantly send $100 Visa cards to reps who booked five demos in a week—boosting pipeline by 23% in one quarter.
Remote Team Engagement
During a virtual retreat, employees received Starbucks cards to enjoy coffee during a morning breakout session—delivered with a custom branded note.
Where to Buy the Best Employee Gift Cards in 2025
Toasty as the All-in-One Platform
Toasty offers:
- Visa and thousands of branded gift cards
- Zero fees
- Customization and scheduling
- Refund tracking
- Group management and analytics
Why Not All Vendors Are Created Equal
Some charge hidden activation or service fees. Others lack tracking, branding, or automation. Toasty stands apart by offering everything in one user-friendly dashboard.
The Future of Employee Rewards and Recognition
AI-Driven Personalization
Expect systems that recommend specific gift cards based on behavior, location, and preferences—automatically.
On-Demand Delivery Triggers
Automate rewards based on milestones in your HRIS or performance software—birthdays, anniversaries, or quarterly goals.
Expanded Global Gifting
More teams, more countries. Toasty’s platform already supports gifting in 90+ countries, and that number is growing.
Conclusion: Choose Smart, Reward Right with Toasty
The best gift cards for employees in 2025 aren’t just convenient—they’re strategic. Whether you’re celebrating wins, appreciating loyalty, or boosting morale, the right card can make all the difference. With Toasty, you get all the features you need—customization, global reach, zero fees, and real-time tracking—in one easy-to-use platform.
Ready to elevate your employee recognition game?
Sign up for free or book a demo to explore Toasty’s game-changing gifting tools.
Sign Up Book a Demo
FAQs About the Best Gift Cards for Employees 2025
What are the most popular employee gift cards?
The Toasty Choice Card, Visa, Amazon, and DoorDash lead the pack for variety and convenience.
Can I send one card and let them choose the brand?
Yes! The Toasty Choice Card allows recipients to choose their favorite.
How much should I spend per gift?
Depends on the occasion—$25–$100 is common. For milestones, go higher.
Can gift cards be taxed?
Yes, they’re generally considered taxable income. Toasty offers downloadable reports for compliance.
Are digital gift cards more secure?
Absolutely. They’re trackable, re-sendable, and can’t be lost like physical cards.
What if the employee doesn’t redeem it?
Toasty's refund feature returns 70% of unredeemed funds to your budget.