Incentivizing sales teams is nothing new. But how you do it has evolved—and one of the most effective tools today is the use of digital gift cards for sales incentives. They're fast, flexible, and friction-free. But how do they stack up against traditional physical gift cards?
Let’s break it down: digital vs. physical gift cards—the pros, the cons, and which one reigns supreme for modern sales reward programs.
Why Gift Cards Work for Sales Incentives
Sales incentives drive performance. Whether you're recognizing top reps, celebrating milestones, or incentivizing pipeline growth, gift cards are universally appreciated and easy to distribute.
Why they work:
- They’re immediate and flexible rewards.
- There's no need for personalization guesswork.
- They support everything from small wins to major achievements.
- They’re perfect for both in-office and remote teams.
What Are Digital Gift Cards?
Digital gift cards—also called eGift cards—are rewards delivered electronically via email or SMS. Recipients can redeem them online or in-store and even add them to their digital wallets like Apple Pay or Google Pay.
Common types of digital gift cards:
- Retailers (Amazon, Target)
- Food delivery (DoorDash, Uber Eats)
- Visa and Mastercard virtual cards
- Experience-based cards
- All-in-one "choice cards" like Toasty’s
What Are Physical Gift Cards?
Physical gift cards are traditional plastic cards that are mailed or handed out in person. They require physical handling, shipping, and sometimes include activation fees. While they feel more tangible, they come with some serious downsides—especially for scaling incentive programs.
Digital Gift Cards: 5 Key Advantages
1. Instant Delivery and Convenience
Digital gift cards can be sent in seconds. Whether it’s an impromptu reward or a scheduled campaign, digital delivery means no delays.
- No shipping times
- Great for remote or hybrid teams
- Last-minute reward? No problem.
2. Cost Savings on Fees and Shipping
Most physical cards come with:
- Activation fees ($2.95–$6.95 per card)
- Shipping costs (especially for bulk orders)
- Loss-related reissuance fees
Digital cards avoid these entirely—especially platforms like Toasty Card, which offers zero-fee delivery.
3. Customization and Branding
Want your sales rep to feel truly recognized? Add your:
- Company logo
- Personalized message
- Campaign-themed design
With digital platforms like Toasty, this is built-in.
4. Easy to Track and Manage
Physical cards go out of sight. Digital ones can be:
- Tracked on a dashboard
- Monitored for redemption status
- Easily resent if lost
This visibility helps you prove ROI on your sales incentives.
5. Environmentally Friendly
Digital gifting eliminates plastic waste, packaging, and shipping emissions. For sustainability-minded companies, it’s the obvious choice.
Physical Gift Cards: 3 Downsides to Consider
1. Lost or Stolen Cards
Once mailed or handed out, physical gift cards can get lost—especially in bulk distributions. And recovery? Not guaranteed.
2. Delayed Delivery and Logistics
Shipping delays, lost packages, or failed deliveries can derail a campaign. And coordinating physical orders takes time.
3. Limited Branding and Customization
Forget dynamic visuals or messaging. Physical cards rarely offer:
- Personalized designs
- Occasion-specific themes
- Company logos
They're generic, and they feel that way.
When Are Physical Gift Cards Still a Good Option?
There are times when a tangible gift makes sense:
- In-person events or conferences
- Executive gifting
- Holiday presents in branded packaging
But for ongoing sales incentives? Digital is more scalable and cost-effective.
Why Digital Gift Cards Are Better for Sales Incentives
Let’s recap why digital gift cards are built for sales reward programs:
- Fast delivery = real-time motivation
- Remote-friendly = perfect for hybrid teams
- Lower cost = better ROI
- Easier to scale and track = more strategic insight
The Best Platform for Sending Digital Gift Cards
Toasty Card is purpose-built for businesses needing to send digital rewards efficiently and affordably.
How Toasty Card Streamlines Incentive Programs
- Bulk Uploads: Upload a CSV and send hundreds of cards in minutes.
- Custom Branding: Add your message, logo, and design.
- No Fees: What you send is what they spend.
- Track Everything: Delivery, redemptions, bouncebacks.
💡 Pro Tip: With Toasty’s Choice Card, recipients can redeem their gift for hundreds of popular brands—including Visa and DoorDash.
How to Transition from Physical to Digital Gifting
- Choose a platform (like Toasty Card)
- Digitize your recipient list (names, emails)
- Customize your rewards
- Send & track
- Evaluate campaign performance
In less than an hour, you can go from planning to sending hundreds of digital sales incentives—something nearly impossible with physical cards.
Real-World Examples: Digital Gifting in Sales Programs
📈 SaaS company rewards SDRs: After every demo booked, reps receive a $25 digital gift card instantly via Toasty.
🎯 B2B sales team contests: Weekly leaderboard winners are sent $50 eGift cards with custom messages from leadership.
🌍 Global teams: International sales reps can be rewarded just as easily—Toasty supports 90+ countries.
Final Thoughts: The Clear Winner for Modern Incentives
Digital gift cards for sales incentives aren’t just the future—they’re the present. They save time, reduce costs, increase motivation, and align with remote and digital-first work environments.
If you want a reward system that scales with your business, digital is the only choice that makes sense.
Sign-Up Book a Demo
FAQs about Digital Gift Cards for Sales Incentives
Are digital gift cards safe to send via email?
Yes. Platforms like Toasty Card use secure delivery and tracking to ensure successful and safe redemptions.
Can I track which recipients used their digital cards?
Absolutely. Toasty Card offers real-time redemption tracking.
What if the recipient doesn’t receive the gift card?
You can easily resend it at no extra cost—Toasty even lets you know if an email bounces.
Can I send gift cards internationally?
Yes. Toasty supports digital delivery to over 90 countries.
Do digital cards expire?
Most digital gift cards don’t expire quickly—but always check terms. Toasty’s Choice Card has flexible terms.
Can I personalize each digital card?
Yes! Add a name, message, logo, and more for each recipient.