Digital Gift Cards vs. Prepaid Cards: What Works Better for Business?

Gifting and incentives are no longer just “nice-to-haves” in business—they’re essentials. Whether it’s employee recognition, sales motivation, or customer loyalty, choosing the right type of reward matters. The two most popular options? Digital gift cards and prepaid cards.

But which one actually delivers better results for your business?

In this guide, we break down the differences, highlight real use cases, and show how tools like Toasty help you deliver both—without the guesswork or fees.

Understanding the Basics: Digital Gift Cards vs. Prepaid Cards

What Are Digital Gift Cards?

Digital gift cards are eGift cards tied to specific retailers or service providers (like Starbucks, Amazon, or DoorDash). They’re sent via email or SMS and can usually be added to a mobile wallet.

🟢 Great for: Brand-based recognition, client thank-yous, and flexible employee perks.

What Are Prepaid Cards?

Prepaid cards, like Visa or Mastercard, are “open-loop,” meaning they can be used anywhere the network is accepted. These can be physical or virtual and are commonly used for broader incentives.

🟢 Great for: Broad-use rewards, international gifting, and sales bonuses.

Key Differences Between Digital Gift Cards and Prepaid Cards

Flexibility in Redemption

• Prepaid Cards can be used almost anywhere.
  
  
• Digital Gift Cards are limited to the issuing brand but offer convenience and targeted appeal.
  
  

Branding and Customization

• Digital Gift Cards often allow more personalization (custom messages, templates, occasion-specific visuals).
  
  
• Prepaid Cards offer limited visual branding but provide broader spending power.
  
  

Distribution Speed and Scalability

• Both are fast—but digital gift cards edge out prepaid cards in ease of instant email delivery with zero activation lag.
  
  

Fees and Costs

• Prepaid Cards often include activation fees—unless sent via platforms like Toasty, which absorbs those costs.
  
  
• Digital Gift Cards usually have no added fees.
  
  

Usage Tracking and Analytics

• Toasty and similar platforms track delivery, redemption, and engagement for both formats—critical for campaign reporting and ROI evaluation.
  
  
  

When to Choose Digital Gift Cards

Ideal Use Cases

• Thank-you gifts for webinar attendees
  
  
• Employee birthdays or work anniversaries
  
  
• Niche recognition moments (e.g., “coffee on us”)
  
  

Top Benefits for Teams and Customers

• Emotionally meaningful: Personalized brand ties (e.g., giving a Starbucks card to a known coffee lover)
  
  
• Easy to schedule and automate for recurring events
  
  
• No fees or confusion on redemption
  
  
  

When to Choose Prepaid Cards

Ideal Use Cases

• Sales SPIFFs or quota-based rewards
  
  
• Global team recognition (Visa is widely accepted internationally)
  
  
• High-value milestone incentives (>$100)
  
  

Top Benefits for Incentives and Sales Teams

• Universal spending power
  
  
• Higher perceived value than brand-specific cards
  
  
• More practical for personal needs (groceries, bills, etc.)
  
  
  

Comparison Table: Digital Gift Cards vs. Prepaid Cards

How Toasty Solves for Both

Why choose one when you can have the best of both?

The Toasty Choice Card

Toasty’s signature option allows recipients to select from thousands of brands, including Visa, Amazon, Target, Uber, and more.

🟢 You don’t have to guess what your team wants—they choose.

Fee-Free Prepaid Visa and Brand Cards

Unlike most vendors, Toasty absorbs:

• Activation fees
  
  
• Delivery charges
  
  
• Maintenance costs
  
  

🟢 What you pay is what your team receives—every time.

Real-Time Tracking and Refund Options

• See who opened and redeemed
  
  
• Resend failed deliveries instantly
  
  
• Recapture 70% of unused funds back into your budget
  
  

🟢 Smarter spending with transparent ROI

Conclusion: The Right Reward for the Right Moment

Both digital gift cards and prepaid cards have their place in business. The key isn’t choosing one over the other—it’s knowing when to use each.

• Go digital gift card when personalization, speed, and branding matter most.
  
  
• Go prepaid card when flexibility, scale, and broad use are critical.
  
  

Thanks to platforms like Toasty, you can send either type with zero fees, full tracking, and powerful engagement tools.

Ready to start gifting smarter?
Sign up for free or Book a demo to explore all your gifting options.

Sign Up   Book a Demo

FAQs: Choosing Between Digital and Prepaid Cards for Business

Are prepaid cards always better than digital gift cards?

Not always. Digital gift cards work well for quick, lower-value, or brand-aligned gifting. Prepaid is better for higher flexibility and value.

Which option works best internationally?

Prepaid Visa or Mastercard (especially via Toasty) are ideal for international teams. They convert currencies automatically and are accepted globally.

Can I send either option in bulk?

Yes! Toasty allows bulk uploads, customization, scheduling, and delivery for both.

What about tracking and analytics?

With Toasty, you can track delivery status, redemptions, and even campaign-level engagement.

Can recipients lose their cards?

Digital cards can be resent instantly. Prepaid physical cards are more prone to loss—choose digital for added security.